A1: ~Surgeon(x46) v Parent(x46, y47) v Operate(x46, y47) A2: ~Operate(x49, y48) v Surgeon(x49) A3: ~Operate(x51, y50) v ~Parent(x51, y50) A4: ~Parent(x55, y54) v Father(x55, y54) v Mother(x55, y54) A5: ~Father(x57, y56) v Parent(x57, y56) A6: ~Mother(x59, y58) v Parent(x59, y58) A7: ~Operate(CA, CS) A8: Surgeon(CA) A9: ~Father(CA, CS) A10: ~Mother(CA, CS) S11: ~Surgeon(CA) v Parent(CA, CS) Res(1,7) {y47/CS, x46/CA} S12: Parent(CA, CS) Res(11,8) {} S13: Father(CA, CS) v Mother(CA, CS) Res(12,4) {x55/CA, y54/CS} S14: Mother(CA, CS) Res(13,9) {} S15: F Res(14,10) {}